Frog Ponds & Flutes

*An Introduction*

Our family lives in Vermont-me, my husband and our son, as well as at least one furry family member at any given time. There is a lovely frog pond on our property that has its own vibrant, year round life cycle. Frogs, peepers, newts, giant beetles, duck families, leeches, dragonflies and sometimes even a turtle are all present, coexisting. Other times the pond is covered in golden leaves and still others in ice thick enough for skating and pond hockey.

Much like the life of a frog pond, this page may change and cycle through stages. Sometimes it may be about flutes and other times not at all.

Last weekend, my little grand-daughter, who is totally at home with nature, with the help of my husband, collected 25 newts as new “pets,” housing them in a somewhat too small fish tank. Not too sure about the humane aspects of that or the ecological soundness, but the enthusiasm and curiosity were to be applauded. They were all ultimately returned to their more natural habitat, but not before being given the love that only a five-year old can shower upon newt families. I guess I wish that I liked slimy newts better than I do-I was chastised for not wanting to hold the new pets after asserting that perhaps some things are better appreciated from a distance.

The frog pond, which I love for its teeming life and the artistry that only nature can provide, like so many things, is perhaps best left to live without too much human interference-only the occasional dipping of nets by science-minded grandchildren. I don’t have any larger connections to make-only that we pass our frog pond several times a day all year long and like a life in music, our pond is often surprising in not only what comes out of it, but by the depth of its variation, and what amazingly different responses we all have when engaged by its vitality.

Blogs follow, with most recent posts first

September 7, 2022

*Wibb, Salamanders, and Mr. Frost*

It’s been awhile since I have written-because, as well you know-it’s been a day, as they say. A very long day. Our family has been very lucky to ride out everything unscathed, but others have been far less fortunate and it felt frivolous to write flute musings. But, flute playing was, as it always has been, a saving grace for me, and I truly hope that everyone had one thing that got them through each day. I am deeply indebted to all who helped me find my self and a voice in the flute.

This past spring, one fine morning with lowering skies, there was a post in my little local listserv, from an organization called “The Hartford Salamander Rescue Team.” I could repost the whole listing, and am sorely tempted. It is so very Vermont. In short, that night was going to be a really big night for amphibians, specifically frogs and salamanders. We all know that I’m partial to frogs, and certain small members of our family are quite devoted to salamanders, so the posting caught my attention straight away. Frogs and salamanders, or sallies as we call them in our family, were being called to their habitats due to an especially rainy night in the offing, and would be clogging up the local roadways in droves. The sallie rescuers were asking us Vermonters to stay off the roadways if at all possible, and also putting the call out for volunteers to shepherd these amphibian friends, with flashlights, headgear, and reflective vests, across our dark and wind swept roads, to their ponds and local watering holes of choice. The team also recommended a training video for neophyte amphibian crossing guards, if one needed to get refreshed on the proper techniques. The team have rescued, impressively, by their own count, over 600 amphibians. How the count was obtained is an interesting question, but these folks seem very sincere, not to mention devoted, so I think we can give it to them. Yay Vermont-it is so totally bizarre but also so incredibly wonderful.

William Ingham Brooke Bennett, OBE, referred to in the flute world by his initials, Wibb, was one of the most influential flute players around. There is a lot of information about him out there to be had, so I won’t go through it all but he was not awarded the OBE for no reason. He played with almost every major British orchestra and made over 100 recordings with almost every major artist of his generation. Wibb was a passionate teacher-he taught at leading UK and European institutions, and famously, to flute players anyway, had his own summer school: The International Flute Summer School. And that doesn’t even get into who he taught, his work on the evolution of the modern flute scale, his life long affiliation with the British Flute Society etc etc. He was also famously humorous, and irreverent, at one point saying that his hobbies were wine making and cock-roach baiting, and that all his life he had been dogged by good luck. Sadly, Wibb passed away this last May at the too young age of 86. The outpouring of memories, love, and tribute to him was in keeping with the legacy that he left behind.

Most striking in the memories and stories so many flute players shared on social media and in many flute association publications was the personal impact Wibb had on so many people. He wasn’t just a good teacher, or just an amazing flutist. He touched people, and made them feel seen, heard. My own connection to William Bennett was brief, but no less impactful for its brevity-and his generosity towards me was of the sort you don’t hear about too often. He gave me a push when I needed one. And was kind beyond all expectation. And also with the famous twinkle and appreciation of all things amusing.

One of my first LP’s as a young flute player was William Bennett’s recording of the Mozart Flute Quartets. It was just brilliant. I loved it. I also heard him all the time on our local Bay Area classical AM radio station (for those not familiar with back-in-the-day radio, AM stations were as opposed to FM stations, not something occurring only in the morning)-they loved St. Martin’s-in-the-Field, one of the many orchestras Wibb performed with, so he was always present on the airwaves and in my ‘72 Volkswagen Squareback, which only had AM radio and not even a cassette player (another antiquity of the past).

So, when I learned, on returning home to Oakland, CA for the summer-having just finished a desultory freshman year of college-a year filled with struggle and adjustments and disappointments, that William Bennett was coming to California to teach a week long masterclass, my brain went into a spasm of excitement. I had of course missed all the application deadlines, and-well, this was 1981ish, there was no internet or email. Hard to remember or imagine, but info was at the library or in journals or by word of mouth. And you sort of had to be industrious and clued in to do thrilling things, and I was really neither at that point. BUT, I was lit up about maybe seeing him teach, maybe getting a lesson, and maybe getting out of my hideous summer job for a day.

So…I picked up another tech dinosaur of the dark ages, the rotary telephone attached to our kitchen wall and I called the Asilomar Conference Center, a very chic events place in the Monterey Bay coastal area, about 120 miles south of Oakland. As it happened, he had not arrived yet, but now quite undaunted and on a roll, I left a message with the front desk leaving my name and our family phone number. A few days later, I happened, luckily (no voice mail back then), to be in the kitchen when the phone rang. Usually, at that time of the morning, it was the personnel department of my hideous job wanting me to come in on my day off. So I had developed a technique I thought was clever of pretending not to be me…if you declined coming in when they called you were punished with horrible hours the next week, so I just pretended I was out for the day and took a message for my so-called self…but on this morning it was the phone company operator asking me if I would accept a collect call from William Bennett…I was stunned. Of course I said yes, and then quickly heard his crisp, British accent asking, in friendly tones, if he knew me?

We chatted, I explained my hubris in leaving such a message, and also how much I loved his playing, that I had been in Baltimore all year at school so had no idea this was happening…etc etc I was your basic begging, flustered, 19-year old. He couldn’t have been nicer or more gracious. After a bit, probably just to end this gushing, ridiculous phone call, even if it was on my parent’s nickel, he invited me to come to the class for a day, at no charge. Unbelievably…and I still wonder about myself at this point…I asked if I could bring a friend! I mean really…I guess that’s the beauty of being 19. Being totally gauche without apology, or awareness. But he, still ever gracious, and perhaps slightly (I hope) amusingly appalled, said sure, why not? My name, plus guest, would be given to the front desk.

Immediately I called my dear friend Liz, a fellow flute player and longtime friend (as it turned out a friend of 40+ years), always up for adventure, and also usually ready for an escape from her own hideous summer job, and boom. We had a plan! We called in sick to our jobs, had our flutes with us, and left at 5am the next day for Asilomar in my powder blue Volkswagen Squareback.

After the morning class, where we heard amazing flute players and saw amazing teaching, and heard Wibb’s long-time collaborative pianist, Clifford Benson, play wonderfully with everybody, I worked up my nerve to introduce myself. Liz, always much braver than me, was egging me on, urgently asking me, while not so lightly shoving me forward, what was the point otherwise? Much to my surprise, then and now, he seemed actually delighted to meet me. Hello? Maybe it was just wonderment at my continued ability to be persistently ghastly, but he offered to hear me play-after he had some lunch. I could come to his room and he’d give me a brief lesson.

At the appointed time I found his rooms, and played whatever I had been working on at the time-I honestly can’t remember what it was-but do remember the time as inspirational, in a room strewn with his and his wife’s clothing, the 45 minutes of flute capped off with drinking red wine together out of a bottle on the dresser. He couldn’t have been more encouraging or more positive, which was exactly what I needed after a tough year. He talked about color, about the music, and the importance of the interior of the music. Finally, he invited me to come to his famous summer school, in August, and to consider that I had just had my audition. The summer school, mind you, took place in England…so of course involved not only airfare, and tuition, but not working for two weeks. After expressing my gratitude (I’m pretty sure I did that) I explained I couldn’t possibly afford it. At which point, again amazingly, he offered me free tuition, room and board. All I had to do was get there.

Probably you already know, and have most likely read, the very famous poem by Robert Frost, “The Road Not Taken.” It is often misunderstood to mean that you should follow your dream, that it makes a difference to do so. In this case, whether misunderstood or perfectly understood, the poem is apt. There I was, a flute-y traveler, standing in a room filled with other people’s underwear, drinking wine with my idol, looking down at the undergrowth of my diverged paths. And unlike the sallies on a rainy night in Vermont, I had no one with light-up headgear and a reflective vest to make sure I figured out how to get on that airplane. Probably not exactly as Mr. Frost imagined his literary bucolic scene, but somewhat similar in tone nonetheless. Yes, I had Liz…but, like me, she had parents who were basically camping out in their backyard and eating beans every day to afford college tuition. So it was impossible. Liz and I had wine that night in our room, toasted each other, and simply enjoyed the good fortune of the day.

But…as the poem is meant to say…the path that day was what it was. And the one I took, in the end, was just as fair. The day with Wibb taught me many, many things and was an unparalleled gift of generosity to a young, silly, flute player. And like salamanders and frogs on a rainy night, I did end up making it across the road in the end, and, by the way, holding the phone number of William Bennett’s famous teacher, Geoffrey Gilbert in my hand!

Rest In Peace, William Ingham Brooke Bennett, OBE (February 7, 1936 – May 11, 2022)

And Liz always and forever, Elizabeth Comte Reisman (October 4, 1963 – January 9, 2019)

If you would like to make a donation via NAMM to the Liz Reisman Fund supporting School Music Education please follow the link below for more information:

June 20, 2017

*Sudden Clarity*

Just a bit over a year ago Morpheus came into our lives.  Morpheus is a cat-a bengal, and as such walks a bit on the wild side. Morpheus is one of the most astounding pets we’ve ever had-I’m not naturally a cat-oriented person, but in the case of Morpheus, I have drunk the kitty-ade, or eaten the kibble, or something along those lines.  Morpheus loves to play, he loves a cozy lap, he greets us at the door, he loves to curl up in the chair in the flute room, he loves Faure and Debussy, and when none of that is working for him, he turns into a wild man and decides he’s a tiger and we…are the prey.

My dear husband is, in fact, a cat-oriented person and has loved all the cats we have had for their unique personalities and little eccentricities, and seems to understand the cat brain pretty well.  In an effort to give Morpheus something to do other than attack us when bored, Jay put up three bird feeders all within close proximity of one another, right in front of the doors to our deck, three sets of French doors in our living room.  The feeders can be seen from a variety of vantage points-two living room spots where hiding and viewing are possible, a sun room location, the master bathroom window, and even from a kitchen window sill. All awesome viewing-hunting locations, and without any real harm to our bird friends.  And, as famously said in a questionable late 80’s movie, build it and they will come. 

It turns out that birds are voraciously hungry all the time, they are very picky about the seed they like, they are quite territorial with one another, the blue jays will even fight the squirrels, and they are all un-deterred by the approach of winter.  Why go south when the eating is good here? And the humans so well-trained? And the one wild animal clearly no threat at all, safely lurking behind the sofa on the other side of the glass?

As the weather has cooled (we’ve even had a first snow-in mid-October) and the leaves have fallen off the trees that surround our house, we can now see, with sudden clarity, all the birds lined up and sitting on the tree branches watching and waiting.  They go back and forth between the branches and feeders in some order they all seem to understand.  Only rarely tussling with one another, despite the several varieties.  The funny thing is, clearly, they were there all along.  We just couldn’t see them.  And we didn’t think about it either-whether we could or couldn’t see them, whether they were waiting in the trees, flying around randomly or with purpose.  I’m not sure I could even say we took it for granted that birds were living their lives just beyond our windows-that we thought much about it at all.

How many things are like that? How many things need just one action to make them visible? One catalyst to change how we see even the most prosaic of events, or the most extraordinary silent events?  Not to mention the big things we walk past every single day.  Without comment, without thought, without seeing.  If the attempt to entertain Morpheus can open our eyes to one event, maybe it would be good to imagine Morpheus with us everywhere, guiding our vision.  

And so, finally, as of course the world in its entirety relates to flute somehow…pianist Matthew Odell and I are looking forward, with our fall programming coming to a close, to some of our spring programming: bird music-we often say to one another “more birdsong!,” so we decided to do a birdsong concert.  Music of Jan Krzywicki, Olivier Messiaen, Gary Schocker, and Shalumit Ran, April 7th, 4pm, at Dartmouth College.  

November 7, 2018


*Time Travel*

Long, long ago, in a galaxy far, far away…was a time when my son responded to my suggestions of super fun activities-great tv shows to watch together, cool museum trips, fun LEGO sets, and the like-with something other than a polite, monosyllabic grunt. A superficial noise acknowledging that words, by me, had been spoken and warranted some, but not much, response.

Back in those glorious olden days, one of our favorite tv shows was the new “Dr. Who” series. We were pretty devoted. We struggled through missing the old doctor and adapting to the new doctor. It was especially hard to say good-bye to David Tennant, but eventually we came to appreciate Matt Smith. Well, it took me awhile anyways. We both struggled with the dark affect of Christopher Eccleston.

That is the way of life I guess-some adapt to change super quickly, adopting the new with aplomb and adventure, and others hang on to what they know, struggling to understand why what they know is no longer enough. The great thing about all the “Doctors” was, that as they grappled with the understanding that however much they knew, or however desperate they were to defeat their arch enemy, the Daleks, their existence as Time Lords was weirdly human. Affected profoundly by time while being simultaneously oblivious to its effect.

My flute studio, and flute practice, these days, resembles a jumbled up, less blue, definitely less Dalek-infested, but equally time-confused Tardis. I have been for some years now trying to understand the ancestors of the “modern” flute, and by extension the people who played them. The time travel we all make, as musicians, in a single practice session can be mind-boggling. Of course one reads treatises, old method books, obtains facsimile editions and crazy fingering charts. But nothing is really like trying to grapple with an instrument that was someone else’s reality. Whether an extremely accurate reproduction or the real McCoy.

When you read that Mr. Nickleson, of 1850, had a really big sound, or that M. Drouet had a very sweet sound, one cannot but have the immediate point of reference be what we know-our powerful, reliable modern flutes. When you play a simple system classical or romantic era flute (six finger holes and a handful of oddly located spatula-like keys)-you immediately realize you are on a wooden Tardis. A Time and Relative Dimensions in Space vehicle. The best part being the sudden awareness of a world that we understand existed, and now suddenly can walk out into, through the door of our metaphorical blue phone booth. These flutes are full of color-in part created by their beautifully imperfect scales, full of subtle gradations made possible by multiple fingerings for the same notes, demanding to the player technically and intellectually.

One of the most satisfying things about these journeys backwards in time, is that they bring into focus the context of all we do, and the air we literally breathe in and out. The worlds may no longer literally co-exist, but they inform each other profoundly. Having developed some capacity with the baroque flute, I now try to bring something of that instrument and its sensibility to the modern flute. And oddly, by applying the purist approach of the Historically Informed Performance practice world, I have become more broad-minded in my approach to Bach or Telemann. Or by playing Mozart on the classical flute (just as poorly as he would expect) I better understand his G Major Concerto to be filled with wit, and fun, rather than the seriousness of the time-and-time-again BIG audition concerto; music with room for laughter and a wink, as well as perfection and clarity. And to better understand the ethereal beauty of the slow movements. The sound of my Grenser can be as ephemeral as clouds.

My two flutes that are actually from their time periods-well, they know things. There is no question in my mind that the music other flutists have given them lingers. With my Meyer of Hannover 11-keyed Romantic Era flute, I have discovered the dark, lamenting soul that Schubert heard. And Chopin’s youthful Variations on Cinderella-a piece I learned way back when, then promptly forgot about-has sprung to life again, sprite-like and charming. My 1871 Louis Lot-it’s eerie how well he knows Afternoon of a Faun. I am just along for the ride. And Roussel’s Joueurs de Flûte-he knows that one pretty much by heart.

These wonderful flutes ask one to listen. They are intrepid travelers, wanting us to see with open eyes, ears and heart; to find deeper nuance in all the worlds that interconnect with one another. They are much like the Doctor, with a new Companion, exploring the previously hidden to any soul willing to make a journey.

February 14, 2018


*Donatoni, the Big Suit, and Birdsong*

Recently my colleague Matthew Odell-the amazing pianist with whom I am so lucky to be able to work regularly-and I performed an incredible piece of music: Franco Donatoni’s “Fili.”

People that know us know that we have a perfectly terrible addiction to, and perverse desire to play,  music that not only keeps us awake at night with worry but tortures our families and friends with cacophonous fragments for months on end, all the while we wonder why in the world we do this to ourselves, asking each other whose good idea was this, and, at the same time, plotting the next excursion into what only vaguely resembles tonality and rarely exploits that Holy Grail of resolutions, the almighty V – I.

Donatoni’s “Fili” was our most recent adventure along these lines, and aside from the worry and travail, and without apparent concern as to whether the audience would actually enjoy this music or not, we had the most fun ever! We promised ourselves all summer long that we would rehearse this music together “a lot” and would not leave it to just a few lengthy, brain damaging rehearsals. Well, that didn’t happen, and we probably did cause permanent injury to ourselves. But we did, as we always do, start slowly, worked with a metronome, had great moments of hilarity along with great moments of discovery, and in the end, the audience whooped triumphantly at the blazing finish.

If you want to know more about Franco Donatoni, there is great information online about him and his music, and several excellent performances of his work on YouTube. That’s not really what I am writing about now, but rather, about the journey made in discovering this piece, deciding to obtain it (it took three months to cross the Atlantic to make residence in my library), and ultimately scratching the surface with our tired fingers.

We are generally in agreement about our repertoire goals, a.k.a. bucket list of crazy pieces. Every so often, my colleague, whose knowledge of 20th and 21st century music is encyclopedic, and has experience to match, will make a suggestion pointing me in the direction of something I would have never thought about at all.  In this case, “Fili” was on a recording we both own that includes the Boulez Sonatine (one of our past adventures).  I had been solely focused on the Boulez, trying to figure out how to count twenty totally confusing measures of rest while the pianist plays a lot of extremely mind-boggling music, and I freely admit I had not listened to the whole CD, so focused was I on being able to count beyond ten. Matthew, of course, had listened to the whole CD, and commented, intriguingly, that the Donatoni was an interesting piece, too. When, after finally deciding with regard to those twenty measures that no one could count them, and that a flare gun was needed to alert the woebegone flutist that it was time to play again, I moved forward in listening and onto Donatoni, and indeed, WHAT a fabulous piece. So the question then boiled down to programming, time and place.  Not if, but when?

One of the great things about this kind of challenge is the way it peels away the layers of habit, and asks questions of one that shake up what you think you know already-about your music making, about how you learn and hear, and about yourself in interaction with others. When I started in on learning this piece, it was a mystifying tangle of fragments and threads, just as the title promises-fili. Fili, in Italian, means threads, or filaments. And the music, to me, explores that ephemeral quality of dialogue that is the best of all conversations-the things that are seen, and heard, but never have to be literal or explained with didactic precision because the dialogue is that wonderful sputtering discovery of like minds.

If you are of a certain generation, or have a not-so-secret love of alt rock or even, dare I say it, some punk music from the 80’s and 90’s, then you know the Big Suit. David Byrne’s genius costuming idea for the 1984 Talking Heads live concert film, Stop Making Sense. The idea is that Byrne’s business suit, as the music continues, becomes bigger and bigger until it is absurdly large-and his head accordingly appears smaller and smaller. His own explanation of this idea is that music is very physical and our bodies understand it before our heads do. The costuming idea was drawn from, Byrne has said, traditional Japanese Noh and Kabuki theater. That expression is indeed what I experienced with Fili. My body began to understand the music before my head did. My physical self became so immersed, so big, with the rhythms and ideas, that when I let go, I could play it. During our first real rehearsal I said “this is just like the Talking Heads!!!!!” My colleague, who pretends to know nothing about pop music, looked at me blankly. I went on to exclaim, “you know…the Big Suit? Stop Making Sense? This is not my beautiful house?” However, whether or not he is deeply familiar with that amazing song “Once in a Lifetime,” it doesn’t really matter, I know he knows the sentiment. And after our second rehearsal when it appeared that we could play it together without getting completely bamboozled, we entered that realm where one can stop making sense of it all, and just live it.

The other thing I realized while working on Fili, and this is brief…is that, once again I had found myself as but one voice in an aviary of sound. The tweets, the chirps, the flutterings, the multitude of flapping wings, and the plaintive cries of one lone bird looking for its  flock are all embedded in the fragments and filaments of time, and played out, as so often falls to fluters, in all the little black dots and notations on the page and staff, written out in an approximation of a language beyond our scope of understanding, and in existence before that of our own. As Messiaen wrote, in his preface to the Abyss of the Birds in the monumental Quartet for the End of Time, “…the birds are the opposite to Time; they are our desire for light, for stars, for rainbows, and for jubilant songs.”

“Fili” was performed at Dartmouth College on October 8, 2017


*Afternoon tête à tête*

Like Thing 1 and Thing 2, some pairings are so happily organic as to be immediately and unquestionably perfect. A recent meeting between certain Mssrs. Erard and Lot in Ashburnham, Massachusetts at the Frederick Historic Piano Collection proved to be one of those exquisitely “right” occasions. Like two old friends meeting again to retell old stories and share new ones over a croissant and chocolate, or a glass of Bordeaux and some good stinky cheese, my Louis Lot flute and a gorgeous Erard piano had a lively time together for a few hours of music making.

The old stories were the Reinecke “Undine” Sonata for, as noteworthily (pun somewhat intended) listed by the composer, “Pianoforte and Flute,” and the Widor Suite for, as more usually listed, Flute and Piano. The new stories were the two players-whose more modern hands put the sound waves into the air, and enjoyed every minute of the experience.

I have been the happy current steward of an 1871 Louis Lot flute for about a year now, and I must say, that while the mechanism can certainly behave like a cranky old man, the sound that comes out and the way the flute guides me is always worth the effort and care. I call him “Mr. Fussy.” He doesn’t like cold. He doesn’t like too much heat. He doesn’t like humidity. He doesn’t like car travel. But he does like Debussy, Poulenc, and Reinecke. He seems to love performing. And he loved being with his friend Erard again.

What I know about the Erard piano company could be fit inside a thimble, but I do know that like the Lot flute company, the Erard company survived many changes over the years-its pianos favored by the likes of Mendelssohn and Ravel, and many of the surviving instruments, like Lot flutes, are not just quixotic period pieces, but fine instruments to be learned from, played and savored. These amazing instruments give insight and meaning not only to the music of the time, but to our present day interpretive practice. They ask us to be not so loud, or so bright, or in such a hurry. They ask us to listen for more color, for the often intriguing imperfection of scale in harmony, for voices that are full rather than brash, atmospheric rather than soft, and not always so “easy” to sound the “same” on every day. Consistency, while obviously good in many respects, maybe, I wonder, leads us to a sort of ephemeral satisfaction? Ultimately less satisfying by its sameness.

In any case, we had fun-my excellent pianist colleague, Matthew Odell, and myself, and I like to think that these two fine gentlemen, having maybe met before, were joyous at being reunited for an afternoon tête à tête, in a small New England town, June 29, 2017.

%d bloggers like this: